Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms pass Commons despite Labour rebellion

Shabana Mahmood‘s immigration reforms have passed the House of Commons despite opposition from some Labour MPs, clearing a major parliamentary hurdle as the government moves to tighten Britain’s asylum and settlement rules.

According to a report by LBC, the Immigration and Asylum Bill passed its final Commons stage on Tuesday by 290 votes to 94, giving the government a majority of 196. It will now proceed to the House of Lords for further scrutiny.

Fourteen Labour MPs voted against the legislation at its third reading, including Diane Abbott, John McDonnell, Nadia Whittome and Bell Ribeiro-Addy, highlighting divisions within the governing party over the proposed changes.

The legislation, introduced by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, seeks to accelerate the removal of failed asylum seekers, change the period of protection initially granted to refugees and establish a new independent immigration appeals authority.

Bill introduces faster removal of failed asylum seekers

One of the major provisions would allow immigration authorities to begin removal procedures without providing the existing five working days’ notice.

The proposed change is intended to speed up the process of removing people whose asylum applications have been rejected, reducing the time between a failed application and the start of enforcement action.

The reforms also propose reducing the initial period of refugee leave from five years to two-and-a-half years.

The government says the changes are part of a wider effort to address weaknesses in the immigration system and close legal loopholes that can delay removals.

Mahmood described the package as the “most significant migration reforms of modern times”, arguing that the measures would make the system more effective.

New immigration appeals authority proposed

The legislation also provides for the creation of an independent immigration appeals authority.

The proposed body would form part of the government’s changes to the process through which immigration decisions can be challenged.

However, the reforms have attracted criticism from Labour backbenchers, particularly over provisions affecting refugees and the conditions under which migrants can qualify for permanent residence.

Bell Ribeiro-Addy was among the Labour MPs who voted against the Bill. She criticised the proposed settlement arrangements, warning that permanent residence could be “bought and flogged to the highest bidder”.

Labour concerns force changes to settlement proposals

The government had already dropped a proposal earlier in November that would have increased the waiting period for settlement for lower-paid work visa holders.

The change followed concerns raised by Labour MPs about the potential impact on workers who provide essential services.

Under the revised arrangements, health and social care visa holders earning at least £25,000 annually will remain eligible to apply for settlement after five years, provided they satisfy the relevant visa conditions.

However, some Labour MPs wanted the exemption extended to a wider group of skilled workers.

Neil Duncan-Jordan, Labour MP for Poole, introduced an amendment seeking to broaden the categories of workers who would qualify for the five-year settlement route.

The proposal was rejected by 368 votes to 44.

Ministers defend exemption for care and public service workers

Home Office minister Anna Turley defended the government’s decision to retain the exemption for care workers and certain public sector health and education employees without degree-level qualifications.

She described the arrangement as exceptional, pointing to the contribution made by these workers during and after the Covid pandemic.

Turley also argued that Duncan-Jordan’s amendment could weaken existing English-language and criminality requirements for people seeking settlement.

The disagreement exposed competing concerns within Labour over how to reform immigration rules while recognising the contribution of workers in essential public services.

Read also: Germany’s criticism of US policy on Ukraine’s deep strikes exposes Western divisions

Labour MPs divided over immigration policy

The rebellion by 14 Labour MPs demonstrated that Mahmood’s proposals have not secured unanimous support within her own party.

Among those opposing the legislation were prominent Labour figures Diane Abbott and John McDonnell, alongside Nadia Whittome and Bell Ribeiro-Addy.

Despite the opposition, the government secured enough votes to pass the Bill through its final Commons stage.

The result means the legislation can now move to the House of Lords, where peers will have an opportunity to examine its provisions and propose changes.

Opposition parties criticise the government’s approach

The debate also featured criticism from opposition politicians.

SNP MP Pete Wishart accused Reform UK MP Sarah Pochin of “quasi-racism” following her contribution to the immigration debate.

Meanwhile, Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said the legislation represented “some small steps in the right direction”.

However, he argued that Britain would not be able to exercise full control over its borders without leaving the European Convention on Human Rights.

His remarks indicate that the Conservatives believe the government’s proposals do not go far enough, while some Labour MPs have raised concerns about the impact of the reforms on migrants and refugees.

Immigration Bill faces further scrutiny in the Lords

With the Commons approving the legislation by 290 votes to 94, attention will now shift to the House of Lords.

Peers are expected to scrutinise the proposed changes, including the faster removal process, the shorter initial period of refugee leave and the new arrangements for immigration appeals.

The legislation has already undergone changes following objections from Labour MPs, particularly over settlement eligibility for workers in health and social care.

The next stage will determine whether further amendments are made before the Bill can complete its parliamentary passage.

For Mahmood, the Commons vote represents progress towards implementing the government’s immigration reforms. However, the Labour rebellion and criticism from opposition parties show that the proposals remain contested as they move to the upper chamber.

READ MORE: Ireport247news

About The Author

Hot this week

US green card fee exemptions cover 11 categories of foreign nationals including Nigeria

US green card fee exemptions allow certain foreign nationals...

Kogi: Army arrests 47-year-old man after discovering 300 bullets hidden in sack of beans

A routine intelligence-driven security operation in Kogi State has...

Germany’s criticism of US policy on Ukraine’s deep strikes exposes Western divisions

Germany's criticism of US policy on Ukraine's deep strikes...

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, giving Democrats 56-44 Senate majority

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race to defeat Republican...

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance ahead of Trump talks in China

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance as Chinese...

Topics

US green card fee exemptions cover 11 categories of foreign nationals including Nigeria

US green card fee exemptions allow certain foreign nationals...

Kogi: Army arrests 47-year-old man after discovering 300 bullets hidden in sack of beans

A routine intelligence-driven security operation in Kogi State has...

Germany’s criticism of US policy on Ukraine’s deep strikes exposes Western divisions

Germany's criticism of US policy on Ukraine's deep strikes...

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, giving Democrats 56-44 Senate majority

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race to defeat Republican...

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance ahead of Trump talks in China

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance as Chinese...

Trump’s Quad meeting in Manila highlights regional security and technology tensions

Trump’s Quad meeting in Manila brought together the United...

YABATECH dismisses report of student’s killing in suspected cult clash

The management of Yaba College of Technology (YABATECH), Lagos...

Related Articles