Ibadan court dismisses defamation lawsuit involving Anglican priest

The National Industrial Court in Ibadan has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by a former Anglican priest, ruling that it lacks jurisdiction to hear defamation matters.

The National Industrial Court sitting in Ibadan has dismissed a defamation lawsuit instituted by a former priest of the Ibadan North Anglican Diocese, Reverend Oluwadamilola Ebenezer Kosemani, against the Archbishop of the Ibadan Ecclesiastical Province, His Grace, the Most Reverend Williams Aladekugbe.

National Industrial Court

The suit, which generated significant interest within ecclesiastical and legal circles, stemmed from an internal communication written by Archbishop Aladekugbe to the Primate of the Church of Nigeria (Anglican Communion), Most Reverend Henry Ndukuba.

The letter, dated November 11, 2024, reportedly addressed issues relating to Reverend Kosemani’s conduct and status within the Church.

Aggrieved by the contents of the letter, Reverend Kosemani approached the National Industrial Court seeking multiple reliefs. These included an order nullifying the letter, a formal retraction by the Archbishop, and a public apology.

He also demanded ₦100 million as general and aggravated damages, alleging that the communication amounted to a defamation lawsuit against his person and reputation.

In a well-considered judgment delivered by Honourable Justice J. D. Peters, the court declined jurisdiction and dismissed the suit in its entirety.

The trial judge held that the National Industrial Court, being a specialised court established under the Constitution, does not possess the legal authority to adjudicate on defamation claims.

Justice Peters emphasised that the jurisdiction of the National Industrial Court is clearly circumscribed by statute and constitutional provisions, primarily covering labour, employment, trade unions, and related industrial matters.

According to the court, entertaining a defamation lawsuit would amount to an unlawful expansion of its jurisdiction.

“The court cannot clothe itself with powers it does not have,” the judge stated, stressing that jurisdiction is fundamental and must be determined before any substantive issues can be considered.

In reaching this conclusion, the court upheld the submissions of counsel to the Archbishop, Otunba Kunle Kalejaye, SAN. Kalejaye led a team of seasoned legal practitioners, including Sir Oyewale Akinrinade, Chief Olusola Orobode, Oyewale Oyegoke, Esq., and Miss Toluwani Ogunbanjo.

The defence team had argued that Nigerian courts have consistently held that defamation claims fall outside the purview of the National Industrial Court, regardless of whether the dispute involves an employer-employee relationship or internal organisational communication.

They urged the court to strike out the suit for want of jurisdiction.

Justice Peters agreed with the defence, noting that several decisions of the Court of Appeal have firmly settled the issue.

After an extensive review of relevant legal authorities, the court struck out the action and dismissed the defamation lawsuit in its entirety.

Reacting to the ruling, Otunba Kalejaye, SAN, expressed deep satisfaction with the outcome of the case.

He praised the court for adhering strictly to established appellate decisions and for resisting any attempt to stretch its jurisdiction beyond constitutional limits.

According to the senior advocate, the judgment reinforces the principle that litigants must approach the proper forum when seeking redress.

He described the dismissal of the defamation lawsuit as a victory for the rule of law and judicial consistency.

Kalejaye further revealed that the dispute could have been resolved without litigation.

He disclosed that the Primate of the Church of Nigeria had earlier constituted a committee of senior priests to mediate and arbitrate in the matter.

However, he claimed that Reverend Kosemani declined to cooperate with the committee, thereby frustrating efforts at an amicable settlement.

“The Church provided an internal mechanism for dispute resolution, but those efforts were rebuffed,” Kalejaye said, adding that litigation should always be a last resort, especially in religious institutions.

When contacted for comments after the judgment, Archbishop Aladekugbe declined to speak on the legal details of the case.

He, however, expressed gratitude to God for what he described as a peaceful conclusion to the matter.

The Archbishop also appreciated the Primate for his intervention and for setting up a reconciliation committee, which he said was unfortunately ignored by the junior priest.

Legal observers say the ruling serves as a reminder to litigants to carefully consider jurisdiction before filing actions in court.

The dismissal of the defamation lawsuit underscores the importance of understanding the limits of specialised courts and the appropriate avenues for resolving disputes, whether legal or administrative.

Ireport247news

About The Author

Hot this week

Israel opposition bloc unity faces test as Netanyahu seeks to exploit divisions

Israel opposition bloc unity is facing a serious test...

Yahaya Bello tells El-Rufai to exercise restraint, reconsider approach to APC disagreements

Former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, has weighed in...

Trump’s 2028 Republican succession audition puts Vance and Rubio under pressure

Donald Trump turned a White House press conference into...

Jeffrey Epstein’s Russia connections involved young women, oligarchs and failed Putin ambitions

Jeffrey Epstein’s Russia connections extended beyond his interest in...

INEC reveals why voters’ register clean-up will not happen before 2027 elections

Nigeria’s electoral commission has postponed a planned nationwide exercise...

Topics

Israel opposition bloc unity faces test as Netanyahu seeks to exploit divisions

Israel opposition bloc unity is facing a serious test...

Trump’s 2028 Republican succession audition puts Vance and Rubio under pressure

Donald Trump turned a White House press conference into...

Jeffrey Epstein’s Russia connections involved young women, oligarchs and failed Putin ambitions

Jeffrey Epstein’s Russia connections extended beyond his interest in...

INEC reveals why voters’ register clean-up will not happen before 2027 elections

Nigeria’s electoral commission has postponed a planned nationwide exercise...

Tinubu-Atiku Legal Battle: Court fixes December 2 for substantive hearing

The legal battle over President Bola Ahmed Tinubu's eligibility...

Lagos APC tells Pearse to stop revisiting Tinubu’s academic controversies

The Lagos State chapter of the All Progressives Congress...

Related Articles