The legal battle over President Bola Ahmed Tinubu‘s eligibility for the 2027 presidential election has encountered another development, with a Federal High Court in Abuja refusing to allow former Vice President Atiku Abubakar and the African Democratic Congress (ADC) to introduce additional documents and modify their existing court processes.
The decision followed a disagreement between the parties over whether the proposed changes were necessary corrections or an attempt to introduce new allegations into a case that had already been formally presented before the court.
Delivering his ruling on Friday, Justice Inyang Ekwo held that the plaintiffs could not use an application for amendment to introduce fresh evidence outside the timeframe permitted by the Constitution.
He subsequently rejected their request, maintaining that the proposed changes went beyond what could legally be accommodated in a pre-election dispute.
Although the ruling does not determine the central allegations against Tinubu, it places an important procedural obstacle before Atiku and his party as they pursue their challenge to the President’s participation in the forthcoming election.
The judge’s position was that parties involved in pre-election litigation must comply with the strict requirements governing the filing of their cases and supporting documents.
He specifically relied on Section 285(9) of the 1999 Constitution, which provides a 14-day period for instituting such actions.
Justice Ekwo was particularly concerned that the proposed amendment would allow the plaintiffs to replace existing evidence with new materials after the constitutionally prescribed period had elapsed.
He reasoned that accepting the request would create an unfair situation for the defendants, who had already responded to the original case based on the documents and allegations initially presented to the court.
In explaining his decision, the judge emphasised that pre-election cases are time-sensitive and that parties cannot disregard the deadlines established by law.
“This is a time-bound suit and the law makes it mandatory for all exhibits to be filed in court within 14 days of occurrence of the event being challenged,” Ekwo stated.
He further maintained that evidence presented outside the stipulated period could not be accepted, adding that the application had failed to satisfy the requirements of the law.
The court consequently dismissed the request and scheduled December 2 for the hearing of the substantive matter.
Disagreement over additional documents
The controversy surrounding the rejected application began when Atiku and the ADC approached the court on September 10, asking for permission to revise the originating summons through which they commenced the action.
They argued that certain inaccuracies had been discovered in the initial documents and that adjustments were necessary to properly establish the issues they wanted the court to examine.
One of the proposed corrections involved the identification of an electoral document, which they initially described as Form CF001 but subsequently sought to identify as Form EC9A.

Their request was not limited to correcting the document’s description. They also wanted to provide more specific details of the alleged fraud, introduce a written deposition by Atiku and submit clearer copies of supporting exhibits.
The plaintiffs maintained that some of the additional materials had not been available when the original action was filed, making their inclusion necessary for a fuller presentation of the case.
However, the defendants viewed the application differently. Their legal representatives argued that the proposed changes would substantially expand the original proceedings and introduce issues that were not contained in the initial court documents.
Why Tinubu’s legal team objected
President Tinubu, through his lawyer, Chief Wole Olanipekun (SAN), strongly opposed the request. The APC and INEC also asked the court to reject the proposed amendments.
Olanipekun argued that the plaintiffs were attempting to present a major alteration of their case as a simple correction of clerical mistakes.
According to the President’s counter-affidavit, the proposed changes would affect the questions submitted for judicial determination and expand the reliefs being sought from the court.
The defence also alleged that Atiku and the ADC intended to introduce an additional prayer that was not part of the original originating summons.
Another issue raised concerned the introduction of fresh documents and additional paragraphs into the affidavit supporting the action.
Tinubu’s legal team argued that the proposed replacement of Form CF001 with Form EC9, alongside the additional documentary materials, demonstrated that the plaintiffs were seeking to change the foundation of their case.
The President’s lawyers further questioned why particulars of alleged fraud were now being introduced through the amendment application if the original court processes had already contained sufficient details to establish the claims.
They maintained that an originating process that was fundamentally defective could not be repaired through an amendment filed outside the constitutionally prescribed period.
The defence also challenged the timing of the original lawsuit, arguing that it was filed after the deadline for commencing the action had expired.
According to Olanipekun, the event being challenged occurred on July 11, when Tinubu’s name was submitted to INEC, while Atiku and the ADC did not file their case until August 14.
Although INEC published the particulars of the presidential candidates and their submitted credentials on August 1, the President’s lawyers insisted that the relevant date for calculating the limitation period was July 11.
They argued that the Constitution determines the permissible period for instituting pre-election matters and that the court’s Practice Direction cannot override those provisions or extend an expired deadline.
Akin Olujinmi (SAN), who represented the APC, and Alex Izinyon (SAN), counsel to INEC, also opposed the application.
The certificate dispute behind the lawsuit
Beyond the procedural disagreement, the substantive case centres on questions raised by Atiku and the ADC concerning documents allegedly submitted to INEC as part of Tinubu’s credentials for the 2027 presidential election.
A major aspect of their complaint relates to an NYSC discharge certificate which Atiku claims was presented in the President’s name through the APC.
In his supporting affidavit, the former Vice President alleged that the certificate carries the name “Tinubu Bola Adekunle” rather than Bola Ahmed Tinubu.
He questioned whether the document was genuinely obtained by the President and challenged its use in connection with the electoral process.
On the basis of these allegations, Atiku and the ADC are asking the court to disqualify Tinubu and the APC from participating in the 2027 presidential election.
The action, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1888/2026, lists Tinubu, the APC and the Independent National Electoral Commission as defendants.
Attention shifts to December hearing
Friday’s decision has settled the immediate disagreement over whether Atiku and the ADC can introduce the additional materials they proposed. However, it has not brought the wider dispute to an end.
The substantive case remains before the Federal High Court, with December 2 fixed for further proceedings.
The next stage will focus on the issues raised in the original action, including the plaintiffs’ challenge to the documents allegedly submitted to INEC and the legal objections presented by the defendants.
For now, the court’s refusal to permit the amendments means Atiku and the ADC will have to proceed within the limits of the existing court processes as the substantive dispute moves forward.

