Donald Trump’s latest Gaza peace proposal has sent ripples across the globe, producing a wave of optimism among world leaders but a mixture of scepticism and weary hope from Palestinians who have endured almost two years of devastating conflict.
Announced in Washington alongside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the 20-point plan outlines an immediate ceasefire, an exchange of hostages for prisoners, the gradual withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza, the disarmament of Hamas, and the formation of a transitional governing authority run by an international board.
Trump, who has returned to the center of Middle East diplomacy after years of division, framed the initiative as the clearest route to end the cycle of violence that has killed tens of thousands and displaced millions.
The plan has been embraced with cautious approval by a wide range of Arab and Islamic nations including Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Egypt, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Turkey, Pakistan and Indonesia.

Leaders from these countries praised the effort as a long overdue attempt to move toward de-escalation and pledged cooperation with Washington in implementing its stages.
European capitals also signaled support, with French President Emmanuel Macron declaring that Hamas “has no choice but to follow this plan” while British Prime Minister Keir Starmer urged all parties to seize the moment and “end the misery.”
Such statements give the Trump proposal an unusual breadth of international backing, particularly in light of recent moves by the United Kingdom and several EU states to recognize Palestine as an independent state, a step that shifted diplomatic dynamics in favor of Palestinian aspirations for sovereignty.
Yet in Gaza itself, responses were far more restrained. Many residents expressed outright doubt about the practicality of the proposal, given its central condition that Hamas renounce governance of the strip and disarm fully—demands they see as non-starters.
Ibrahim Joudeh, speaking from southern Gaza, dismissed the plan as unrealistic, saying it was built on preconditions that Washington and Tel Aviv know Hamas will reject. Abu Mazen Nassar echoed the sentiment, describing the initiative as manipulation that asked Palestinians to release prisoners without binding guarantees of ending the war.
Their voices reflect the deep mistrust that years of failed ceasefire deals have left across Gaza, where displaced families live in overcrowded shelters and amid rubble from Israeli bombardments.
In Israel, however, parts of society greeted the plan with guarded hope. Demonstrators in Tel Aviv who have been pressing for the return of hostages saw in Trump’s announcement a glimmer of relief.
Inbar Hayman admitted she was hopeful but remained fearful of disappointment, having witnessed previous agreements collapse. Gal Goren, who lost both parents during the Hamas-led attack of October 2023, said she felt heard for the first time when Trump recognized the plight of hostage families and spoke of bringing them home.
The proposal also contains provisions that could reshape governance in Gaza. It envisions a transitional authority supervised by an international “Board of Peace” chaired by Trump himself, tasked with running the territory until the Palestinian Authority completes a program of reforms.

Among its members is former British Prime Minister Tony Blair, a figure who stirs controversy across the Middle East due to his association with the Iraq war.
Mustafa Barghouti of the Palestinian National Initiative criticized Blair’s inclusion, saying Palestinians had already experienced the consequences of British colonialism and viewed him with distrust.
Still, the Palestinian Authority welcomed Trump’s initiative, calling for it to be used as a foundation for a comprehensive settlement rooted in a two-state solution, something international observers argue is the only viable endgame for the decades-long conflict.
Diplomatic veterans in Washington have also thrown their weight behind the deal. Brett McGurk, a former senior national security official, called it a “good deal” that places the burden squarely on Hamas given the wide international consensus behind it.
Dan Shapiro, Barack Obama’s former ambassador to Israel, described it as credible but stressed the importance of strong pressure from Qatar and Turkey to bring Hamas on board. The alignment of Arab and Western states around a single framework is a rare occurrence in Middle East diplomacy, and analysts say it represents a critical opportunity—if the obstacles of implementation can be overcome.
On the ground in Gaza, opinions remain fractured. Some residents, despite their doubts, cling to hope simply because they see no other option. Anas Sorour, a street vendor, said that after so much pain and loss he still believed God willing there could be a moment of joy to erase suffering.
Yet others like Mohammed al-Beltaji remain cynical, describing the peace process as a repetitive game in which one side accepts and the other refuses, while ordinary people continue to pay the highest price. That price remains staggering: Israeli airstrikes killed at least 30 people in Gaza the same day the plan was announced, underscoring the urgency of a genuine ceasefire.
Trump’s decision to personally head the proposed Board of Peace has sparked debate among observers. Supporters argue that his involvement could lend weight and urgency, especially given his influence over Netanyahu and his ability to secure buy-in from Gulf states.
Critics counter that it risks turning a fragile diplomatic initiative into a personality-driven spectacle, vulnerable to collapse if domestic U.S. politics intervene. Still, the symbolism of a former U.S. president placing himself at the helm of Gaza’s transitional governance underscores the stakes of the moment.
The broader international community sees in this proposal a chance to pivot from endless conflict toward stability. For the Biden and Obama alumni who now comment from the sidelines, the deal represents both continuity and a departure: continuity in the sense of pressuring Hamas through regional allies, but a departure in openly recognizing Palestine as part of the endgame.
For European powers facing refugee inflows and rising public pressure over Gaza’s humanitarian crisis, the plan offers a structured path that could relieve tensions. For Gulf states, it provides a mechanism to reassert influence while limiting Iran’s foothold in Palestinian affairs.
Nevertheless, the fundamental challenge remains Hamas. Without its consent, even the most carefully orchestrated deal risks falling apart. The group has so far stayed outside formal negotiations, and its leaders have not indicated willingness to cede governance.

International mediators believe Qatar and Turkey could serve as pivotal intermediaries, but history shows Hamas has rarely responded positively to pressure alone. Until the organization’s stance changes, Gazans may continue to view Trump’s peace plan as another promise destined for failure.
For now, Gaza’s residents remain trapped between despair and flickers of hope. The international stage is lined with leaders urging acceptance, Israeli families of hostages cling to optimism, and Palestinians torn by grief and displacement weigh the possibility of peace against bitter experience.
Trump’s proposal may be the most ambitious attempt yet to end the war, but whether it becomes a historic turning point or another footnote in decades of failed initiatives will depend less on speeches in Washington and more on choices made in Gaza’s shattered streets.
Keyphrases:
Trump Gaza peace plan (main keyphrase)
Donald Trump Gaza proposal
Hamas response to peace plan
Netanyahu Gaza negotiations
Gaza residents sceptical of peace
International support for Gaza ceasefire
Board of Peace transitional authority
Gaza hostages and prisoner exchange
Palestinian Authority reforms
Gaza war ceasefire deal


