Supreme court reserves judgment in Osun State Government allocation case

The Supreme Court reserves judgment in the Osun State Government suit against the Federal Government over withheld local government allocations in Osun.

The Osun State Government has taken a bold legal step to defend its financial autonomy, as the Supreme Court of Nigeria reserved judgment in its suit against the Federal Government of Nigeria over the alleged illegal withholding and diversion of local government allocations belonging to Osun’s 30 Local Government Councils (LGCs).



A seven-member panel of justices led by Justice Uwani Abba-Aji made the ruling on Tuesday, October 7, after both the Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF) and the Attorney-General of Osun State adopted their final written arguments.

The case, marked SC/CV/775/2025, has drawn national attention due to its implications for fiscal federalism and local government autonomy in Nigeria.

The Osun State Government is demanding the immediate release of its local government funds and asking the court to restrain the AGF from diverting them to individuals no longer recognized by law.

The Osun State Government, led by the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) administration, approached the apex court to enforce its constitutional rights over local government finances.

The state is seeking ten reliefs, including a declaration that the Attorney-General of the Federation must respect and implement previous court judgments validating the elections of democratically elected local councils held on February 22, 2025.

According to court filings, the state argued that the AGF acted beyond his constitutional authority when he allegedly diverted statutory allocations to sacked All Progressives Congress (APC) local government officials, in defiance of judgments by both the Federal High Court and the Court of Appeal, which had already nullified those elections.

The Osun State Government maintains that such interference is unconstitutional, undermines the rule of law, and threatens Nigeria’s federal balance.

Appearing for the state, Mr. Musibau Adetunbi (SAN), told the court that despite ongoing litigation, the AGF had written to the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) on March 26, instructing it to release the withheld allocations to the ousted APC chairmen and councillors.

Supreme court reserves judgment in Osun State Government allocation case



Adetunbi said: “My Lords, even while this matter was still before this court, the defendant attempted to destroy the res (subject matter) by directing payment of the money to the dismissed officials. Thankfully, a court order stopped the release.”

He urged the court to grant all reliefs sought by the Osun State Government, insisting that the AGF had exceeded his constitutional powers.

He also requested a perpetual injunction restraining the Federal Government from ever withholding or diverting the state’s statutory allocations in the future.

Adetunbi further emphasized that the funds belong to the local councils and that their diversion to unrecognized persons constitutes an assault on democracy and due process.

Representing the Attorney-General of the Federation, Chief Akin Olujimi (SAN), filed a preliminary objection, urging the Supreme Court to dismiss the case.

He argued that the Osun State Government had no legal right to sue on behalf of the local governments and that the matter was political, not constitutional.

Olujimi contended that the APC local government officials still have a valid three-year tenure, which will expire on October 22, 2025, and accused the Osun government of frustrating them from performing their duties.

He said: “This is a political battle disguised as a constitutional dispute. The plaintiff has made it impossible for the elected officials to function by filing multiple cases to block their access to funds. This does not fall within the original jurisdiction of this court.”

The AGF’s counsel further maintained that the case lacked merit, disclosed no cause of action, and was an abuse of court process.

During the hearing, the court also struck out a related suit, SC/379/2025, filed earlier by the Osun State Government before the AGF’s controversial directive to the CBN.

The Supreme Court ruled that the earlier case had been overtaken by events and that the present suit now covers all related issues.

Legal observers say the case is a critical test of the 1999 Constitution (as amended), particularly Sections 7 and 162, which guarantee the existence of democratically elected local governments and define how federal revenue is distributed.

The Osun State Government insists that under these provisions, no federal authority, including the AGF, has the power to interfere with how local government funds are managed once they have been allocated to a state.

After hearing both sides, Justice Uwani Abba-Aji announced that judgment has been reserved and that the date for delivery will be communicated to the parties.

The court’s eventual decision will determine not only who controls local government finances in Osun but also set a far-reaching precedent for all states in Nigeria.

Analysts believe that a ruling in favor of the Osun State Government could reinforce the constitutional autonomy of states and local councils, marking a victory for decentralization and democratic accountability.

Conversely, if the Federal Government prevails, it could reaffirm the AGF’s oversight powers, reshaping intergovernmental fiscal relations nationwide.

The Osun State Government, however, remains confident that the judiciary will uphold the rule of law and protect the constitutional independence of its local governments.

The outcome of this case is expected to be historic. It will either strengthen the hands of states in managing their own affairs or reaffirm the Federal Government’s authority in disbursing national revenues.

Whatever the judgment, the decision will undoubtedly redefine Nigeria’s constitutional landscape and fiscal federalism.

More news at ireport247news

About The Author

Hot this week

Reps summon NAFDAC, DSS, police over fake drugs as four die after herbal medicine consumption in Benue

The House of Representatives has called for a stronger...

State Police: Tinubu receives constitutional amendment bill after 36 states’ approval

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has received the proposed constitutional...

US green card fee exemptions cover 11 categories of foreign nationals including Nigeria

US green card fee exemptions allow certain foreign nationals...

Kogi: Army arrests 47-year-old man after discovering 300 bullets hidden in sack of beans

A routine intelligence-driven security operation in Kogi State has...

Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms pass Commons despite Labour rebellion

Shabana Mahmood's immigration reforms have passed the House of...

Topics

State Police: Tinubu receives constitutional amendment bill after 36 states’ approval

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has received the proposed constitutional...

US green card fee exemptions cover 11 categories of foreign nationals including Nigeria

US green card fee exemptions allow certain foreign nationals...

Kogi: Army arrests 47-year-old man after discovering 300 bullets hidden in sack of beans

A routine intelligence-driven security operation in Kogi State has...

Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms pass Commons despite Labour rebellion

Shabana Mahmood's immigration reforms have passed the House of...

Germany’s criticism of US policy on Ukraine’s deep strikes exposes Western divisions

Germany's criticism of US policy on Ukraine's deep strikes...

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, giving Democrats 56-44 Senate majority

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race to defeat Republican...

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance ahead of Trump talks in China

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance as Chinese...

Related Articles