Britain’s invisible war: Former MI5 Chief warns Russia has already crossed the line

Britain may already be locked in a hidden conflict with Russia, according to Eliza Manningham-Buller, the former director-general of MI5.

Her stark warning has raised alarm over the extent of Moscow’s hybrid operations, from cyber-attacks and espionage to sabotage and disinformation campaigns, that appear to have crossed the boundaries of traditional peacetime activity.

For Manningham-Buller, this is no longer simply about tensions or diplomatic hostility—it is the reality of a shadow war playing out on British soil and across Europe, largely unseen by the public but deeply felt within the intelligence community.

Speaking in a podcast interview with Lord Speaker John McFall, Manningham-Buller agreed with Russia expert Fiona Hill, who earlier this year argued that Moscow was already at war with the West.

“I think she may be right in saying we’re already at war with Russia. It’s a different sort of war, but the hostility, the cyber-attacks, the physical attacks, the intelligence work is extensive,” she said.

Her words underline how modern warfare is no longer defined by armies crossing borders, but by covert campaigns designed to weaken adversaries from within.

The UK has already felt the impact of this hidden conflict. Earlier this year, six Bulgarian nationals were sentenced for spying on behalf of Russia, part of a network engaged in hostile surveillance across Europe.

In another case, five men were convicted for an arson attack on a London warehouse storing supplies destined for Ukraine, an operation directly ordered by Moscow.

These are not isolated incidents but part of a larger pattern that British intelligence officials believe represents a coordinated Kremlin strategy to disrupt and intimidate.

Cyberwarfare is another battlefield where the conflict is intensifying. British businesses, critical infrastructure, and government networks have been repeatedly targeted by hostile cyber actors suspected of being linked to Russia.

Pat McFadden, the Cabinet Office minister, warned last year that Moscow was stepping up cyber operations with the aid of artificial intelligence, creating an even more sophisticated threat environment.

For victims of these attacks, the damage ranges from financial losses to the compromise of sensitive data, while for the government, the challenge lies in defending against an enemy that can operate anonymously and globally.

The warning also resonates with developments across NATO’s eastern flank, where allies are reporting escalating Russian provocations.

In Poland, nineteen unarmed drones crossed into its airspace this month, raising fears that Moscow is deliberately testing NATO’s readiness and response thresholds. Such incidents blur the lines between military aggression and covert harassment, keeping tensions high while avoiding outright declarations of war.

For Manningham-Buller, the situation marks a stark departure from the optimism that briefly characterized UK-Russia relations in the early 2000s.

She recalled meeting Vladimir Putin in London in 2005 after the G8 summit in Scotland, when some in the West hoped Moscow could be persuaded to act as a partner rather than an adversary.

That hope evaporated within a year with the assassination of Alexander Litvinenko, a former Russian spy who was poisoned with radioactive polonium in a London hotel.

A public inquiry a decade later concluded that the killing was “probably ordered” by Putin himself, cementing the image of a Kremlin willing to carry out ruthless operations abroad to silence critics and project power.

Since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the scope of its activities has expanded dramatically, with hybrid tactics deployed not only against Kyiv but across Western capitals.

The idea of an undeclared war is not just rhetoric; it reflects a growing consensus among security experts that Russia is deliberately operating below the threshold of conventional conflict while achieving the strategic effects of war.

Manningham-Buller’s warning suggests that Britain must recognize this reality rather than waiting for a traditional declaration of hostilities.

Her remarks also touched on the broader geopolitical consequences of Western retreat from global influence. She criticized the UK and US for cutting overseas aid budgets, warning that such moves create an opening for China to expand its diplomatic and economic presence.

Drawing on her experience as chair of the Wellcome Trust, Manningham-Buller recalled visiting African hospitals where US-funded HIV treatment centers provided lifesaving care.

“If we withdraw from the world, they can move in because they have a strong economic base,” she warned, adding that soft power—from the BBC World Service to humanitarian aid and demining programs—remains vital to maintaining Britain’s influence and credibility.

The former MI5 chief’s intervention is likely to fuel debate in Westminster about how to respond to this new form of warfare. Critics argue that the UK has not invested enough in cyber defense, counter-disinformation strategies, or in shoring up international partnerships beyond NATO.

With Russia continuing to probe for weaknesses, the question is not whether Britain can prevent hostile acts entirely, but whether it can build the resilience needed to withstand them without suffering severe disruption.

This sense of urgency is heightened by the memory of past failures to anticipate Russian aggression. Many intelligence veterans admit that Western governments underestimated Moscow’s willingness to use force in Georgia in 2008, in Crimea in 2014, and in Ukraine in 2022.

The risk now, they suggest, is that policymakers fail to grasp the seriousness of Russia’s hybrid war until it escalates into something even more overt and destructive.

Manningham-Buller’s message carries added weight because of her history at MI5, where she oversaw Britain’s domestic security during the turbulent years following the September 11 attacks.

Her career was shaped by responding to unconventional threats that blurred the line between war and peace, and she is acutely aware of how adversaries exploit uncertainty to their advantage.

By declaring that Britain may already be at war with Russia, she is challenging political leaders and the public to rethink what conflict looks like in the twenty-first century.

The implications are sobering. If Britain accepts that it is already in conflict, then its approach to national security, economic resilience, and international diplomacy must change.

That could mean greater investment in intelligence, stronger alliances within NATO and the EU, and a renewed commitment to global soft power initiatives. It could also mean preparing the public for the reality that some disruptions—from cyber outages to covert sabotage—are not random accidents but deliberate acts of hostility by a foreign power.

At the heart of Manningham-Buller’s warning is the recognition that warfare today is not declared with parades or treaties but waged in silence, often unnoticed until the consequences become undeniable.

For Britain, the challenge is to adapt quickly enough to protect itself and its allies, while resisting the temptation to dismiss Russian activity as mere nuisance. The invisible war she describes is not one of the future—it is a conflict already unfolding, and its outcome will depend on how swiftly and decisively Britain responds.

About The Author

Hot this week

Reps summon NAFDAC, DSS, police over fake drugs as four die after herbal medicine consumption in Benue

The House of Representatives has called for a stronger...

State Police: Tinubu receives constitutional amendment bill after 36 states’ approval

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has received the proposed constitutional...

US green card fee exemptions cover 11 categories of foreign nationals including Nigeria

US green card fee exemptions allow certain foreign nationals...

Kogi: Army arrests 47-year-old man after discovering 300 bullets hidden in sack of beans

A routine intelligence-driven security operation in Kogi State has...

Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms pass Commons despite Labour rebellion

Shabana Mahmood's immigration reforms have passed the House of...

Topics

State Police: Tinubu receives constitutional amendment bill after 36 states’ approval

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has received the proposed constitutional...

US green card fee exemptions cover 11 categories of foreign nationals including Nigeria

US green card fee exemptions allow certain foreign nationals...

Kogi: Army arrests 47-year-old man after discovering 300 bullets hidden in sack of beans

A routine intelligence-driven security operation in Kogi State has...

Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms pass Commons despite Labour rebellion

Shabana Mahmood's immigration reforms have passed the House of...

Germany’s criticism of US policy on Ukraine’s deep strikes exposes Western divisions

Germany's criticism of US policy on Ukraine's deep strikes...

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, giving Democrats 56-44 Senate majority

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race to defeat Republican...

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance ahead of Trump talks in China

Xi and Putin challenge Western economic dominance as Chinese...

Related Articles