What would happen If the US stopped supporting Israel tomorrow?

The United States’ support for Israel has been a cornerstone of its Middle East policy for decades, with far-reaching implications for the region and beyond.

Despite growing criticism and calls for reassessment, the US remains one of Israel’s most steadfast allies, providing billions of dollars in military aid and diplomatic backing. But what would happen if the US were to suddenly end its support for Israel?

Internationally, the impact would likely be significant, with many Western states that have traditionally supported Israel potentially moving against it immediately.

Ori Goldberg, an Israeli political scientist, notes that “many of the Western states that originally supported Israel are now feeling particularly helpless and are now really just willing Israel’s downfall upon it.”

Without US backing, these states might impose sanctions or even enact Chapter 7 of the UN Charter, authorizing immediate intervention. Goldberg adds that “it would be quick” and would likely take the form of sanctions or other measures.

Regionally, Israel’s relationship with its neighbors could undergo a significant shift. HA Hellyer, a senior fellow at the Royal United Service Institute and Center for American Progress, believes that the removal of US support would eliminate a major impediment to a potential settlement.

“Israel’s imperative for genuinely integrating itself into the region will always be a second- or third-level priority, because American support underwrites its ability to act with impunity,” Hellyer explains.

He also disputes the notion that Israel is on the brink of being attacked, stating that “this idea that Israel is one step away from being attacked just isn’t the case and, many would argue, hasn’t been the case for decades.”

Financially, Israel would face significant challenges without US support. Goldberg notes that “Israel is very dependent on the US financially, but it wouldn’t collapse entirely.

The country’s high-tech sector, which has benefited from US aid and research opportunities, would likely be severely impacted.

Additionally, Israel’s ability to purchase weapons on a large scale would be compromised, as European countries would charge for their military aid, unlike the US, which has provided significant assistance without charge.

In terms of Israeli politics, the impact of a US withdrawal might not be as significant as one might expect.

Goldberg believes that Israel’s settler community would continue to pursue its goals, regardless of US support, and that Prime Minister Netanyahu would likely survive and reframe the situation to suit his agenda.

Daniel Levy, a former Israeli government adviser, however, notes that US support has given Israel “absolute impunity” in its treatment of Palestinians, allowing politicians to wage war or support settlements without consequence. Without the US, this dynamic could shift, and Israel might face increased accountability.

The Israeli military would also face significant challenges without US support. Hamze Attar, a defense analyst, estimates that Israel could sustain its war efforts for around a year but would become increasingly vulnerable without US aid.

The loss of defense systems like the Iron Dome and Arrow, which are partly funded by the US, would leave Israel more open to attack. Attar adds that Israel would need to seek alternative military suppliers, likely from NATO countries in Europe, but would struggle to afford the necessary equipment.

In Gaza and the occupied West Bank, the situation would likely become increasingly unsustainable for Israel. Levy believes that the central bank and the army would quickly realize that they lacked the resources to continue the war, making it politically and economically unfeasible.

Goldberg agrees, stating that the senior echelons of the army would likely call for an immediate end to the war. HA Hellyer thinks that Israel would adopt a holding pattern, buying time as it faced increased international pressure and accountability.

Without US support, Israel would be treated like an international pariah state, similar to apartheid South Africa, and would be forced to change its behavior.

The US support for Israel is rooted in a complex blend of strategic interests, shared democratic values, and domestic political influence. The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) has played a significant role in maintaining bipartisan support for Israel in Congress.

The US-Israel alliance is built on a powerful narrative of ideological and cultural kinship, with American policymakers justifying unwavering support for Israel through national interest and shared democratic values.

Public opinion in the US is increasingly divided on the issue of support for Israel, with a recent poll suggesting that half of US voters believe Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, and six in 10 oppose further military aid. This shift in public opinion could potentially impact US policy towards Israel in the future.³

About The Author

Hot this week

YABATECH dismisses report of student’s killing in suspected cult clash

The management of Yaba College of Technology (YABATECH), Lagos...

Trump’s Asia summit diplomacy faces major tests as protests greet US visit and Xi hosts world leaders

Trump's Asia summit diplomacy is facing significant challenges as...

Brexit’s impact on Britain’s global standing comes under scrutiny as Burnham signals closer EU ties

Brexit's impact on Britain's global standing has become a...

Emanuel Odiase’s heavyweight title ambitions grow after sparring Oleksandr Usyk

Emanuel Odiase's heavyweight title ambitions are gathering momentum as...

IGP Disu reshuffles police leadership, redeploys DIGs, AIGs, commissioners nationwide

The leadership structure of the Nigeria Police Force has...

Topics

YABATECH dismisses report of student’s killing in suspected cult clash

The management of Yaba College of Technology (YABATECH), Lagos...

Emanuel Odiase’s heavyweight title ambitions grow after sparring Oleksandr Usyk

Emanuel Odiase's heavyweight title ambitions are gathering momentum as...

IGP Disu reshuffles police leadership, redeploys DIGs, AIGs, commissioners nationwide

The leadership structure of the Nigeria Police Force has...

Tinubu orders release of 78 suspects arrested over Abuja convoy attack

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has approved the release of...

Robert Pattinson James Bond casting confirmed as actor replaces Daniel Craig as 007

The Robert Pattinson James Bond casting has been officially...

Related Articles